Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
12 BBQ Pizza
10 Mikes Classic Hero Sub
Veggie Lover Calzone
Veggie Lover Stromboli
About
Main St Pizza
Welcome to the delightful world of Main St Pizza, a hidden gem located at 125 N Main St, Hastings, FL 32145. If you're looking for a warm, inviting spot to enjoy fresh, homemade pizza and more, this charming eatery is the place to be. Offering a range of delicious options, it has quickly garnered a reputation for quality and flavor.
Main St Pizza specializes in handcrafted pizzas that are as generous in toppings as they are in flavor. Customers rave about the crust, noting its perfect texture—flavorful without being soggy. With a 12-inch cheese pizza starting at just $11.99, you can indulge in a satisfying meal that won't break the bank. The menu also features unique specialties, like the buffalo chicken pizza, which has been praised for its tasty toppings (though some customers are hoping for a little more heat!).
- Appetizers: Kick off your dining experience with tempting options such as the Buffalo Wings (10 for $12.99) or the cheesy Garlic Knots (6 for $5.99).
- Desserts: Don’t forget to save room for something sweet—try the rich Chocolate Mousse Cake or the classic NY Cheesecake, each for $4.99.
Outdoor seating enhances the experience, inviting diners to soak up the beautiful Florida weather while savoring their delicious meals. Customers have noted the excellent service, with staff always ready to make friendly suggestions based on personal preferences. For families, there’s a cozy atmosphere that caters to all ages, with hearty options for kids that even satisfy picky eaters.
One of the standout dishes mentioned in customer reviews is the garlic Parmesan wings—crispy and perfectly seasoned. Enthusiasts recommend ordering them extra crispy for an even more satisfying crunch. Coupled with a comforting steak and cheese sub or a fulfilling gyro, your meal is sure to please. Diners have expressed their loyalty, often returning for that comforting taste of authentic Italian food.
So if you find yourself traveling between St. Augustine and Gainesville, make sure to stop by Main St Pizza for a meal that boasts both quality and value. It’s not merely about pizza; it’s an experience defined by friendly faces, delicious food, and the promise of a memorable dining occasion. As one patron aptly put it, “We're coming back!” This statement says it all about the delightful offerings at Main St Pizza.
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ Great garlic Parm wings! Get them extra crispy! Steak and cheese sub, Gyro and pizza all very good. We come often! ”
“ This is a great little place to stop and ran some pizza. All seating is outside so if it's a beautiful day, it's soooo nice! We did not see any high chairs, but we also did not ask as our little one was in a stroller. We ordered a buffalo chicken pizza. It was delicious, however we like a more heat, but that is just a preference. They do not sell by the price or have any type of children's menu. They suggested ordering the meatballs (2 meatballs in marinara sauce) for our 5 year old. We did and she loved them and the sauce. We ended up bringing the rest of the sauce home and put some noodles in it. They have canned drinks and water. No alcohol. I think they were reasonable prices and they were super sweet. Definitely will stop here again! ”
“ Great pizza,crust had nice flavor and not soggy. Toppings were tasty and generous. Glad they covered the side porch!! ”
“ If you're traveling between St Augustine and Gainesville, stop here for pizza and Italian food. Food is fresh and tasty, service is friendly, outdoor seating is comfortable. Really exemplary customer experience. The pizza is first rate, hot and fresh. Meatball sub and Italian subs are outstanding. Seriously, people, enjoy St Aug but get your food on the way home. ”
“ We're coming back! Their food was so good, delicious pizza and garlic knots, that we have decided to dine here again. 5/5 ”
“ Place is delicious, good food, meatballs are delicious, the Mediterranean pizza is my jam.. wish they delivered ”
“ We were in the area and had to try out this new pizza place. Based on prior reviews we got the cheesy garlic knots and they did not disappoint. Soft and cheesy with a large side of marinara. The marinara... it's homemade... it's PERFECT! I wanted the Bianca (white) my husband wanted pepperoni and mushroom. They told us we could split a pizza. It was wonderful! Every bite was heaven. The cheese was stringy and delicious! The staff was helpful and friendly. The breeze on the deck was great on a hot day like today. We will be back! ”
“ this is an easy 5 stars! Just based on the garlic knots alone told me all I need to know, they were delicious! The dough! The dough was light and fluffy, not at all dry or thick, they were perfectly slathered with garlic butter, parm and mozzarella, so freaking good! Me and Michelle were not planning to eat them all but they were so good we devoured them, with a side of equally delicious meatballs in some marinara sauce, yes to all of it! Hastings is lucky to have this gem! :) ”
“ My friend and I stopped in to Main Street Pizza for a few appetizers prior to an event nearby. We ordered at the window and found a seat on the deck. There is no indoor seating. When we walked up to the window, we smelled all the good smells. We ordered cheesy garlic bread, served with marinara and two meatballs smothered in marinara. I'm not a huge bread fan but could not stop eating the cheesy garlic bread! It seemed to melt in my mouth. It was hot, soft and oh so cheesy. And the mariner sauce was perfectly blended with just a little sweetness. We each had a meatball. The meat was tender and flavorful. And it was a big portion. And again with the perfect marinara. The presentation was nice even in to go containers. If you're in Hastings, you must give them a try! ”
